Caricatures of historical figures
Round 3
Image 3 - "Relatively Huge in Paris" : 3.60
The joke is carried entirely by the title while the picture only enlarges, meaning Einstein has been scaled up to tower over the Eiffel Tower but his face, posture and pipe are drawn with photographic respect, so we get a giant rather than a caricature. Relativity offered a real visual gag, a city bending around his mass, clocks melting at the edges of the frame, and the image settles for size alone.
Image 1 - "Sir Isaac and Magnificent Apple" : 4.00
A genuinely sharp conceit hides under the neon: the Times Square ball becomes Newton's apple, so the most famous falling object of every New Year finally gets its physicist, and his bulging eyes and storm of a wig sell the moment of discovery. What smothers it is the billboard noise, that is, the brand logos and screens fight his face for attention, and a quieter crowd around him would have let the apple drop with the weight it deserves.
Image 2 - "Ancestors and Descendants" : 4.10
The most thoughtful image of the day reads evolution in both directions at once, with Darwin embracing the grinning chimp of our past and the glowing robot of our future, all of it laid over a sepia field notebook full of Galapagos sketches and finches. It falls short of the brief by being too fond of its sitter, meaning Darwin is painted as a kindly grandfather rather than exaggerated into a type, so the chimp ends up doing more caricaturing than the great man himself.
Image 4 - "Never Surrender, Never Skip Champagne" : 4.25
This is the one entry that knows the caricature is a British art form and plays it on home ground: Churchill as a jowled bulldog in pinstripes, champagne raised, cigar clamped, standing astride a tank that is also a Union Jack teapot. That teapot is the masterstroke, because it fuses the wartime leader and the national tea break into one absurd vehicle, and the Pol Roger in his hand is a real biographical detail rather than a random prop. Soldiers marching under patriotic umbrellas and Spitfires stitching the sky behind Big Ben push the patriotism to the point of affectionate mockery, which is exactly where Gillray and the Punch cartoonists always aimed. The one weakness is the clutter of postcard emblems, so many flags that the eye has to work to reach the face, and a bolder crop on his expression would have doubled the punch. My winner.
ββββββββββββββ
Three scientists and one statesman, and the statesman won because he was the only one the artist dared to laugh at. Image 2 had the deepest idea in the room and came close, but its tenderness toward Darwin kept it a portrait, while Image 4 understood that a caricature is a portrait with its sleeves rolled up.
Duel: 1 vs 2
Never Surrender, Never Skip Champagne
Judge
π― 4.70 π‘ 4 π 4.20 β€οΈ 4.10
Relatively Huge in Paris
Judge
π― 3.50 π‘ 3.10 π 4.20 β€οΈ 3.60
Duel: 3 vs 4
Ancestors and Descendants
Judge
π― 3.80 π‘ 4.50 π 4 β€οΈ 4.10
Sir Isaac and Magnificent Apple
Judge
π― 4.20 π‘ 4.20 π 3.60 β€οΈ 4
Each duel is picked by the players chosen for it.