Artwork inspired by bas-relief, different materials
Round 7
Image 4 - "A Ride Through Childhood πβ¨" : 3.80
A storybook carved in sandstone with every page open at once: castle, moon, birds, flowers, fence, a galloping dog, and a girl whose hair streams as wildly as the horse's mane. The carving is lovely, above all the hair cut as ridged channels of stone, but the nostalgia is assembled from stock props rather than remembered, meaning nothing in the frame belongs to one particular childhood; a single odd detail, a patched boot, a horse that is plainly a rocking horse, would have turned the fairy tale into a memory.
Image 1 - "A Painful Moment in Sport" : 3.85
The only image that treats relief as something a body can fall out of: the skater's crash shatters the plaster wall, and the fragments flake off her arms like ice off a rink, so the material itself becomes the injury. It loses ground because the break-out-of-the-frame device is a familiar trick and here it is half committed, that is, her face and the arena behind her are photographic while only her sleeves are plaster, so the relief never decides whether it is carving her or merely cracking around her.
Image 3 - "The First Cat on the Moon πββ¬π" : 4.05
The cleverest joke here is the genre: this is a commemorative bronze plaque, the kind bolted to a monument, and it immortalises not a giant leap but a cat leaning back against a crater with a steaming mug, as if conquest were only a better place for a nap. The patina and the layered depth, from the deep-cut boot soles back to the shallow incised Earth and stars, make it the most accomplished carving of the round. What holds it back is a joke that lands completely on the first read and leaves nothing for the second, meaning mug, rocket and paw print all point at the same punchline and none of them complicates it.
Image 2 - "A Nobleman With a Dog" : 4.15
Here "different materials" stops being a recipe and becomes a plot: a faded Renaissance fresco cracks open and the nobleman's own leg, with his hound beside it, comes out in carved and gilded wood, while his painted face stares in pure astonishment at what his lower half has decided to become. It is a comedy of media, painting and sculpture caught mid-quarrel, and the plaster peeling at the break makes the transition read as an event rather than a collage. The acanthus leaves that burst out with the dog echo the gilt scrollwork in the frame's corners, so the escape seems to come from inside the frame's own vocabulary. The flaw is anatomical: the wooden leg joins the painted torso at no hip anyone could own, and the dog's head is carved larger and grimmer than its master, so the joke wobbles where it should be precise; tuck the knee under the doublet and give the hound a courtly scale and it would be a fable. My winner.
ββββββββββββββ
Every image this round had to decide whether relief is a surface or a threshold, and the two that chose threshold, Images 1 and 2, gave the round its pulse. Image 3 was the best made object on the wall and came within a whisker, but its bronze told one joke cleanly while Image 2 staged an argument between paint and wood that keeps unfolding the longer you look.
Duel: 1 vs 2
A Ride Through Childhood πβ¨
Judge
π― 4.30 π‘ 3 π 4.30 β€οΈ 3.60
The First Cat on the Moon πββ¬π
Judge
π― 4.30 π‘ 3.50 π 4.50 β€οΈ 3.90
Duel: 3 vs 4
A Nobleman With a Dog
Judge
π― 4.40 π‘ 4.30 π 3.80 β€οΈ 4.10
A Painful Moment in Sport
Judge
π― 3.40 π‘ 3.90 π 3.90 β€οΈ 4.20
Each duel is picked by the players chosen for it.