The Mirror Disagrees
Round 6
Image 4 - "The mirror knows better" : 2.96
The plainest telling of the oldest wish, meaning the drab cardigan on this side and the jewelled bride under chandeliers on the other are a before-and-after poster rather than a quarrel, and the mirror simply grants what the woman already wants. The hairline cracks in the glass are the one interesting thought, a hint that the dream is breaking even as it shines, and had the bride herself been fractured along those lines the picture would have argued with its own fantasy instead of selling it.
Image 1 - "Face to face with a dream" : 3.30
The tear on the girl's cheek is earned, and the painterly candlelit corridor gives her real loneliness, so this version of the rags-and-crown fable at least hurts a little. What dilutes it is the burst of lens flare blazing from the frame's edge, a cinematic sparkle pasted onto an oil painting, which announces the magic so loudly that the girl's quiet doubt, the better half of the picture, is shouted down.
Image 3 - "Two Lives, One Mirror" : 4.09
Of the three Cinderella mirrors, this is the one with a sense of humour, because casting a moth-eaten stray as the duchess turns a well-worn wish into a fable, and the cat in its emerald gown and pearls carries itself with exactly the composure a cat would demand. The craft is the richest of the evening: the peeling plaster, the dust on the floorboards, the reflected ballroom glowing behind the gilded mirror's rotten edge, all of it holds together. Yet both cats wear the same calm face, so the mirror flatters but never disagrees, and one flicker of envy or disdain passing between them would have given the title its argument.
Image 2 - "Tss..." : 4.20
The only picture tonight in which the mirror tells on someone, and that single turn makes it a thriller in a boy's bedroom. On our side of the glass two brothers or best friends are mid-tumble, all grins and headlock, the very picture of a hug; in the reflection the hugger is alone, finger to his lips, slipping the phone out of the other boy's back pocket, which in the real room still sits safely in place. Everything else conspires with that trick: the cluttered shelves and globe and space posters make it ordinary daylight, the photographic finish makes it feel caught rather than staged, and the shushing gesture recruits the viewer as an accomplice. The one thing I would sharpen is the light in the mirror, which is a touch too even; a colder, harsher cast on the reflected side would have marked it as the world where the truth lives. My winner.
ββββββββββββββ
Three of tonight's mirrors dreamt the same ballroom, and that shared dream became the measure of the round: the cat of Image 3 survived it on wit and sheer painting, while Images 1 and 4 were caught inside it. Image 2 won because its mirror was the only one with a different opinion of the people standing in front of it, and an opinion, rather than a wish, is what a disagreeing mirror owes us.
The mirror knows better
MARY
π― 4 π‘ 2 π 3 β€οΈ 2.50
TAPI
π― 3 π‘ 2 π 3 β€οΈ 2
Judge
π― 4 π‘ 2.60 π 4 β€οΈ 3.40
Two Lives, One Mirror
MARY
π― 4 π‘ 4 π 4 β€οΈ 4
TAPI
π― 4 π‘ 4.50 π 4 β€οΈ 4
Judge
π― 4.30 π‘ 3.70 π 4.50 β€οΈ 4.10
Tss...
RAMA
π― 4 π‘ 4.20 π 3.90 β€οΈ 4.10
BOOM
π― 3.90 π‘ 4.20 π 3.80 β€οΈ 3.90
Judge
π― 4.60 π‘ 4.90 π 4.30 β€οΈ 4.60
Face to face with a dream
RAMA
π― 3.60 π‘ 3.20 π 3.10 β€οΈ 3.10
BOOM
π― 3.20 π‘ 3.10 π 2.80 β€οΈ 3.10
Judge
π― 4 π‘ 2.80 π 3.90 β€οΈ 3.70
Only this tournament's players rate.