Swan Attack - furious swans hissing and charging at some unlucky victim
Round 3
Image 4 - "Angry swan is no joke" : 3.46
Choosing a black swan is the boldest casting decision of the night, a living ink blot with a red beak flung open against a sky cracking with gold. Yet the drama stalls at the shoreline: the boy sits on his heels with his hands raised like a startled audience member rather than a target, so the swan is performing at him instead of attacking him; put him off balance, sliding down the bank in the water's spray, and the picture would stop being a tableau and start being an emergency.
Image 3 - "Poodle dog just tried to play" : 3.52
The title smuggles in the best joke on the table, a victim who has not yet realised he is one, and the poodle bounding through the shallows with tongue out and ears flapping is a perfect portrait of innocent misreading. The trouble is that the picture around the gag is stock weather, a generic storm sky and a generic splash, so the comedy rests on one small dog; give the swan a whiff of the absurd too, a swan who takes this personally, and the misunderstanding would play as a duet rather than a solo.
Image 2 - "Fear Makes the Swan Bigger Than He Is" : 3.64
Here is the sharpest idea of the round: that terror is a magnifying glass, and the swan we flee is always larger than the swan that exists. The comic-book register suits that idea and the panel crackles with motion, the flying feathers, the stumble, the scattering onlookers, but the page shouts so many captions (YIKES, HISSS, FLAP, WHOOSH, KRAK) that the eye spends its energy reading instead of fearing. The concept begs for distortion, a swan that swells into a white thundercloud filling half the sky over a tiny runner; at present the bird is only slightly oversized, so the title promises a psychological truth the drawing delivers as a sight gag.
Image 1 - "Swan Lake in the Storm" : 3.90
This one turns a farmyard nuisance into a scene from a myth: two swans rise out of a marsh in mirrored fury, wings flung wide like a pair of opening gates, while a dawn of pale gold pours through the mist behind them. The inspired twist is the victim, a badger, an animal we expect to be the hard case of the riverbank, here flattened into the mud with its mouth open in alarm, and that reversal of the pecking order is where the humour and the menace both live. The light does the real storytelling, backlighting every flight feather into translucence and catching each droplet of the spray, so the attack feels both violent and strangely ceremonial, the choreography of a ballet the title slyly invokes. It stops short of 4.00 because the two swans are near twins, a symmetry that reads a little designed; had one been lunging and the other still rising, the charge would feel caught rather than staged. My winner.
ββββββββββββββ
Every image tonight agreed the swan was the villain, so the round turned on who found the most interesting victim. Image 2 had the cleverest thought and very nearly took it, but Image 1 let the light and the upturned order of the marsh make its argument without a single word, and that silence carried further than any sound effect.
Angry swan is no joke
Poodle dog just tried to play
Fear Makes the Swan Bigger Than He Is
Swan Lake in the Storm
Only this tournament's players rate.