Ladies at the Ascot Races - elegant racegoers wearing the most outrageous hats imaginable
Round 1
Image 4 - "Where the Hats Outrank the Horses" : 3.05
The title promises a coup and the picture stages a catalogue shoot, which is to say the hats never outrank anything: two tasteful fascinators frame a smiling man in sunglasses, the grandstand wears its logo like a watermark, and everyone is lit with the frictionless glow of an advertisement for sparkling wine. The pink and blue are lovely together, but outrageousness needs a casualty, someone's view blocked, a brim colliding with a top hat, the man visibly losing the contest his title says he lost.
Image 3 - "The Ascot Crown Jewels" : 3.28
This is the most believable day at the races on the table, warm, sunlit and genuinely cheerful, and the tiny carousel horse riding the middle hat while real horses gallop the turf behind is a sly little rhyme. Yet believable is the problem: these are hats you could buy, worn by women who look pleased rather than astonishing, so the image settles into a holiday snapshot; push the carousel idea until the hat becomes a whole spinning fairground and the jewels in the title would finally glitter.
Image 1 - "Ladies First!" : 3.80
The wittiest thought of the round turns the whole parade around: we stand behind the ladies, so the hats become their faces, peacock, rose bomb and blue chiffon wave looking out at us like masks, while a row of top-hatted gentlemen folds into a bow so deep it becomes a collapse, one of them flat on the lawn. It is a comedy of manners written in posture, and it reads in a second. What costs it the day is the knot of men in the middle, where arms, coats and legs merge into one dark many-limbed creature, so the gag tips from courtly into confused; give each bow its own clean silhouette and the joke would land with a bell.
Image 2 - "Royal Ascot - Exceptional View" : 3.93
Here the brief to imagine the most outrageous hat is taken at its word and then outdone three times: a gilded clock smothered in roses, a tall glass bowl of koi swimming above a woman's head, and a nest from which doves are lifting into the air. Read them together and they are time, water and sky worn as headdresses, three small worlds balanced on three silent women, and the aquarium in the centre is the one image tonight that makes you laugh and gasp in the same breath, the fish glowing orange against a grey stand like lanterns. The faces are cool fashion masks and the composition is a flat line-up rather than a scene, which holds it under 4.00, but that stillness also turns the trio into exhibits in a gallery of impossible millinery, and the title's pun, nobody behind them will see a single race, is earned. My winner.
ββββββββββββββ
A duel between a joke and a spectacle, and for a long while the joke was ahead: "Ladies First!" had the cleverest staging of the night and only a tangle of gentlemen kept it from the top. The aquarium hat settled it, because the theme asked for the outrageous and only one picture made the hats themselves the event rather than the setting for one.
Where the Hats Outrank the Horses
The Ascot Crown Jewels
Royal Ascot - Exceptional View
Ladies First!
Only this tournament's players rate.