Sumo Wrestlers Training for Professional Ballet
Round 6
Image 4 — "The Heavyweight Nutcracker" : 3.40
A set change mistaken for an idea. Swapping the plain studio for Clara's Christmas hall buys the picture a good title pun and very little else — the tree lights, the giant nutcracker and the frost-castle backdrop are decoration standing behind the same wide shot of men in tutus. The leaping figure has real elevation and nicely shaped arms, but he wears no expression for us to read, and four dancers spaced evenly across the frame leaves nobody to care about.
Image 3 — "Sumo Ballet Academy" : 3.55
The best-looking stage in the round and the least trusting picture in it. That moonlit Swan Lake backdrop is the prettiest surface anyone painted today and the lead arabesque is genuinely athletic — a real extension, a real line — and then a chalkboard is wheeled into the foreground to announce "SUMO BALLET ACADEMY, TODAY: SWAN LAKE ACT II" in case we had failed to work it out. Captioning your own joke is the surest way to shrink it, and the brief said training, which is a rehearsal room, not a curtain up.
Image 2 — "The first attempt to stand on pointe" : 3.85
The only one who understood that the subject is fear. Hand locked on the barre, eyes down on his own feet, an enormous body organised entirely around one uncertain ankle — the title is delivered precisely, and that low sun raking across the boards through rosin dust is the loveliest light made all week. What holds it a step back is that the feet, the very thing we are asked to watch, are the softest passage in the frame.
Image 1 — "where Dega and sumo meet" : 4.00
Not a joke about big men in tutus — an argument about who belongs in a Degas. Degas spent his life on working bodies in studios, unglamorous and mid-effort, dancers caught tying a ribbon rather than taking a bow, and this picture quietly proposes that the sumo body has more claim on that tradition than the ballerina's ever did. It backs the proposition with actual paint: scumbled ochre floor, cream light entering from the left, dusty pink satin, soft edges throughout, a palette held to four notes. And it chooses the right pose — a man bent over his own ankle, concentrating, entirely unaware of us — so the tenderness arrives a beat before the comedy does. The foreground leg does not resolve under inspection, which is a shame at the focal point, but this is the only entrant who made a painting instead of photographing a punchline. My winner.
where Dega and sumo meet
The first attempt to stand on pointe
Sumo Ballet Academy
The Heavyweight Nutcracker
Only this tournament's players rate.