The price isn't for the object. It's for what other people believe about it
Four forces, all measurable:
-
Contagion. Yale's Newman, Diesendruck and Bloom (2011) asked people how much they'd pay for a sweater owned by a celebrity they admired. Then they said the sweater had been washed. The price dropped. People believe something of the person lingers in the thing. An original painting is valued partly because the artist's hand touched it. A perfect copy has no touch.
-
Story. The Mona Lisa was a respected painting, not the most famous one in the world. Then in 1911 it was stolen from the Louvre and missing for two years. Newspapers everywhere. Crowds came to stare at the empty wall. It came back a legend. Same canvas, new story.
-
Signal. Thorstein Veblen, 1899: some goods are bought because they're expensive. The price is the message. Only a few people on Earth can pay $450 million for a painting, which is exactly why Salvator Mundi sold for that in 2017. It hasn't been publicly shown since.
-
Mimetic desire. René Girard: we want what others want. One bidder makes the second one serious.
And a detail you'll like. Much of the world's most expensive art sits unseen in tax-free warehouses called freeports. Geneva's alone is said to hold over a million works. Bought, stored, never looked at.
So the real answer: price is collective recognition. Remove the recognition, and it becomes a canvas.