Digitization: The Dark Side
**1. Government debt:**.
OECD public debt rose from 73% of GDP in 2007 to around 110% in 2024. That demonstrates a substantial fiscal shift, although debt alone doesn't measure bureaucracy or prove digitization caused it.
** 2. Intelligence:**
There is evidence of declining IQ-test performance in some developed countries. A Norwegian study found that the rise and subsequent reversal in test scores could be identified within families, pointing toward environmental rather than purely genetic explanations. But the trend isn't universal: a large 2023 meta-analysis found continued gains in many populations. So “global IQ is falling” is too broad a conclusion.
**3. Bureaucracy:**.
Hypothesis has an intriguing mechanism. Digitization can make each administrative procedure cheaper, but it can also make it economical to introduce many more procedures, checks, reporting requirements, and compliance systems. Research on digital government has documented cases where self-service technology shifts administrative work from institutions onto citizens instead of eliminating it.
Digitization increases society's capacity to measure, manage, and control things. That capacity can grow faster than society's wisdom about what is worth managing.
We may be building systems that are increasingly sophisticated at administration, finance, consumption, and information processing while degrading the conditions people need for health, intelligence, intimacy, and independence.